There have been gay riots in San Francisco, and Los Angeles, after the democratic process of voting that rejected Same Sex Marriage. They are much like the riots and storming of the Psychiatric association convention in 1973 which resulted in the association’s removal of same sex attraction from the DSM psychiatric manual. So riots work, starting with Stonewall. In Canada, gay marriage is now legal.
After 4 years of legal gay marriage in Canada, the statistics are dismally low and getting lower. The national Gay Paper in Canada, Xtra, recently ran an article called:
“Why most Canadian gays and lesbians are choosing not to marry - MARRIAGE / Too many risks, few incentives”
The article lists some of the reasons gays and lesbians in Canada are not geting married, which are similar to findings in Massachusetts and in the Netherlands where gay marriage is legal. These are quotes from the gay newspaper Xtra, the paper that rallied the gay community to battle against Christians for marriage:
“… For some [in the gay community] same-sex marriage is a radical act … for others it’s an assimilationist strategy…represents a reform movement that seeks to prove that queers are ‘just like everyone else.’ But many of us are not like everyone else - and unapologetically so.
“… Many queers worry that the cultural adoption of same-sex marriage will lead to a domestication of queer culture … But does our vibrant queer culture depend on marginality? Hopefully not. And, as Dan Savage has pointed out, marriage rarely meant monogamy for hets, so why would it make us sexually exclusive?”
“… queers have a distance from which to critique it [marriage], as well as freedom to create the relationships we want … owning property or having a pet is more of a commitment than a marriage … we have built cultures and communities independent of the straight world, developing and adopting our own creative alternatives: chosen families, open relationships, multi-parent families and domestic partnerships, just to name a few ...”
“… Because we have all the same rights and responsibilities as common-law partners that we would have if we married, there is no need to marry …”
“… Gay lawyer Ken Smith points to another disincentive to legalize vows. With marriage rights come obligations; you can’t opt in or out at will …”
“… And besides,” smiles Boo, “I love to wear the prettiest dress in the room.”
“… Many queers regard marriage as an oppressive patriarchal institution and have no interest in participating in it,” findlay notes. “My partner and I, for example, decided that we would not marry unless there was an important political reason to do so. As my partner says, ‘We’ve been living in sin for too long to change now!’”
“… I believe that the more progressive political approach is for the individual to be the basis of social organization instead of the couple … A culture that values the individual instead of the couple as the base unit would offer more support for singlehood and single parenting, for starters … single, polyamorous, coupled, friendship, chosen family or whatever our queer hearts can dream up.”
From: Why most Canadian gays and lesbians are choosing not to marry MARRIAGE / Too many risks, few incentives Xtra Jillian Deri /Vancouver / Thursday, September 25, 2008 (my emphasis)
So there it is, the Gay Marriage issue, which was the result of 20 years of lobbying, riots, court orders, and slander against Canadian Christians for their protectiveness of marriage. Marriage is not attractive to those who battled for it. The queer community says it was more of a political tool than a true passion. Straight Canada negotiated away it’s most precious gift.
Forgive the analogy, but it seems like when a kid who wants a swimming pool, makes his parents life unbearable until the parent gives in, they spend all their savings to buy the backyard pool to make the child happy. Then the kid never swims in it, but instead stands on the deck and pees in it.
The article in Xtra outlines the fundamental difference between gay and straight relationships. Marriage is at it’s heart, a call to selfless giving of oneself, first to spouse and then to the resulting children. Lifelong loyalty is it’s defining and core value. Capital Xtra is saying Gay relationships are built around the individual, where long term loyalty is not a core value.
Perhaps the US should take a cue from the gay community here in Canada, who have finally gotten honest about the issue, now that the Supreme Court and Parliament have put the issue to bed.
David MacDonald